New Zealand Mosque Attack Difficult to Prevent Despite Five Eyes Intelligence Sharing, Experts Say

Lane closures on the Tobin Bridge start April 1. Here’s what to know.
March 16, 2019
What Is a Veto and How Can Congress Override Donald Trump’s on National Emergency Declaration?
March 16, 2019

New Zealand Mosque Attack Difficult to Prevent Despite Five Eyes Intelligence Sharing, Experts Say

On Friday afternoon native time, a gunman carried out an assault on two mosques in Christchurch, New Zealand, killing 49 individuals.

But as individuals throughout the globe mourn, questions have been raised about whether or not the assault might have been prevented with higher intelligence sharing and on-line surveillance.

The alleged shooter seems to have had a major on-line footprint, with photos of his weapons posted on-line earlier than the capturing and an obvious manifesto describing the contours of his white supremacist and right-wing ideology shared on social media.

Recently, some questioned New Zealand’s position within the Five Eyes alliance—a gaggle of nations that additionally contains the U.S., Canada, the United Kingdom, and Australia—which share intelligence amongst one another. Critics have argued that New Zealand ought to be kicked out of Five Eyes for its gradual response to political interference by the Chinese Communist Party. Others, nonetheless, say that New Zealand is just too shut of an ally to close out.

New Zealand Mosque Attack Difficult to Prevent Despite Five Eyes Intelligence Sharing, Experts Say Residents have been evacuated off the road as police investigated a Somerville Street property in Dunedin, New Zealand, believed to be associated to the lethal terror assaults at two mosques in Christchurch, on March 15. Dianne Manson/Getty Images

But many nationwide safety consultants say Friday’s capturing in New Zealand most likely couldn’t have been prevented, even with strong intelligence sharing measures.

“Five Eyes intelligence sharing in my experience did not delve deeply into what we would consider to be domestic terrorism. So any shortfall in this area would not have involved singling out New Zealand for China reasons, or any other,” Nicholas Rasmussen, a nationwide safety and counterterrorism knowledgeable at The McCain Institute for International Leadership, instructed Newsweek. 

“And to be sure, if the U.S. had any information at all that would have pointed to any potential attack by any terrorist, domestic or international, we would have shared that information. Full stop. We have a duty to warn and that extends beyond just Five Eyes partners, indeed to pretty much everybody,” Rasmussen added.

Joshua Geltzer, a Future of War Fellow at New America, agrees that it might have been troublesome to stop the assault regardless of the data shared on-line.  

“Attacks like this one are awful, awful tragedies. They also, depending on how they’re plotted and executed, can be very difficult to detect and disrupt. We’re still learning how this came to pass,” Geltzer instructed Newsweek. “I’m sure the New Zealand government is scrutinizing that quickly and aggressively. Any major policy changes regarding intelligence sharing should allow time for that scrutiny to unfold.”

Leaders in all Five Eyes international locations, together with New Zealand, have urged that they might search methods to entry encrypted private knowledge legally in an effort to thwart terrorist assaults. And some consultants argue that it’s essential for the U.S. to proceed to work with its allies on these points.

“New Zealand has been and stays an in depth and essential companion for the United States and different Five Eyes international locations. We face widespread issues in addressing violent extremism of all varieties,” Tess Bridgeman, a senior fellow and visiting scholar on the Reiss Center on Law and Security at New York University School of Law, instructed Newsweek. “I anticipate that our intelligence communities are cooperating to the fullest extent doable within the wake of yesterday’s horrific assault, alongside our legislation enforcement and diplomatic officers.”

Meanwhile, others have pointed to the simple manner that white supremacy is spreading in on-line chat rooms within the present political local weather.

“The atrocity in New Zealand exhibits us, as soon as once more, that we’re coping with a world terrorist motion linked by a harmful white supremacist ideology that’s metastasizing within the echo chambers of web chat rooms and on social media networks,” Richard Cohen, president of the Southern Poverty Law Center, stated in a press release.

“In this case, a killer attacked Muslims worshiping at two mosques. In November, a killer massacred Jews at a synagogue in Pittsburgh. Though the victims were different, and the attacks came in different parts of the world, the terrorists shared the same ideology of white supremacist hate.”

Comments are closed.